Deutsch English
← back to archive
War & Military · 790 words · MN-260604-0002

Ceasefires without peace: Why violence continues

unabated in the Middle East

Despite multiple formal ceasefire agreements across the Middle East, military attacks persist without interruption. Israel continues its bombardments in Lebanon and Gaza, the United States and Iran are trading periodic fire, and the humanitarian consequences are spilling over into fragile nations worldwide. Legal experts point to a fundamental lack of enforcement in international law as the root cause of the continuing violence.

The current landscape of the Middle East is riddled with contradictions: a ceasefire between Israel and Hamas in Gaza has been in place since October 2025, a truce between the US and Iran since April, and a new US-brokered ceasefire between Israel and Lebanon was announced on Thursday. Yet, on Friday, Israeli attacks on southern Lebanon killed at least five people, including a doctor, and forced displacement orders were issued for nine towns. In Gaza, an Israeli strike killed nine people in a residential building this week. Meanwhile, the Iranian military has fired missiles and drones at Gulf nations like the UAE, Kuwait, and Bahrain, accusing them of enabling US attacks during the ceasefire.

According to legal experts, the persistence of violence lies in the nature of ceasefires themselves. Mark Kersten, assistant professor at the University of the Fraser Valley, explains that a ceasefire is a cessation of hostilities designed to create space for negotiations, but it is typically not a permanent arrangement. Emeritus professor Michael Lynk from Western University notes that unlike peace treaties, ceasefires often lack guarantors responsible for oversight and enforcement. This is particularly evident in Lebanon and Gaza, where the United States acts as the principal broker but is also Israel’s closest military and diplomatic ally. Lynk emphasizes that while Global North countries criticize Israeli attacks, they fail to hold Washington accountable for allowing Israel to repeatedly breach these agreements.

agreements.

British international human rights lawyer Toby Cadman argues that the problem is not a lack of legal standards but rather their selective application. International humanitarian law remains fully applicable during a ceasefire, meaning allegations of war crimes can still be investigated. However, there is no neutral arbiter empowered to determine with binding effect who has breached an agreement. The international legal system suffers from a severe enforcement deficit. The UN Security Council is constrained by veto powers, the International Court of Justice cannot enforce its own binding orders, and the ICC relies on states to execute arrest warrants. The fragility of these agreements was further highlighted when US President Donald Trump defined the ongoing US-Iran exchanges by saying: “In that part of a ceasefire is when you’re shooting in a more moderate manner.”

In Lebanon, political friction is mounting over foreign interference. Lebanese Prime Minister Nawaf Salam urged Iran to stop treating his country as a “bargaining chip” to improve its negotiation terms. President Joseph Aoun also told Iran, “It’s not your country, it’s our country,” and stated that Hezbollah must pursue diplomacy. However, analyst Andrea Dessi cautioned that any deal excluding Hezbollah is destined to fail. Israeli diplomat Alon Pinkas acknowledged that Israel’s goal of destroying Hezbollah is unachievable without occupying the entire state of Lebanon, which he described as unviable and immoral. Hezbollah leader Naim Qassem rejected the ceasefire as a “surrender and defeat,” claiming his forces launched multiple attacks against Israeli military positions in southern Lebanon.

The human toll of the continued hostilities is devastating and far-reaching. In Lebanon, the death toll from Israeli attacks has risen to 3,526, with over a million people displaced. The UN’s humanitarian agency OCHA has doubled its aid appeal to $640 million over the next six months. Healthcare is collapsing, with 62 hospitals damaged or closed and over 100 paramedics killed. The education system is also under severe strain, with 450 schools repurposed as shelters.

Beyond the immediate conflict zones, the US-Iran war is triggering a global food crisis. The UN World Food Programme (WFP) warns that the ongoing conflict and its effect on oil prices—exacerbated by the near-closure of the Strait of Hormuz—have profound implications for global food security. Fragile nations dependent on imported energy and food are being hit hardest. In Somalia, 6.5 million people are expected to face severe hunger in 2026, while 17.4 million could be affected in Afghanistan. In Sri Lanka, up to 1.3 million people risk being unable to meet basic food needs. The WFP also warned that rising operational costs and local food prices are causing a “double squeeze,” meaning the agency will serve 1.5 million fewer people than planned in 2026, and if the conflict continues for six months, over 9 million people could lose assistance entirely.