Grab What You Can: The New Reality of Territorial
Disputes in the South China Sea
A staggering transformation is underway in the South China Sea. Antelope Reef, a small, teardrop-shaped feature in the Paracel Islands that was almost entirely underwater until recently, has been reshaped in just six months. Millions of tonnes of sand have been dredged from the seabed, turning a turquoise speck on the map into a 6-sq-km crescent of gleaming white sand with dozens of cutter suction dredgers still at work. According to BBC, this extraordinary pace likely sets some kind of world record, but China is no longer alone in this practice. After years of watching China build islands to back its expansive territorial claims, Vietnam has embarked on a massive dredging spree of its own, while the Philippines is also reinforcing its footholds.
The Paracel and Spratly Islands remain fiercely contested by China, Taiwan, Vietnam, the Philippines, Malaysia, and Brunei. China, which took control of the Paracels in 1974, has previously turned reefs into militarized island bases and claims almost the entire sea within its infamous nine-dash line, patrolling the waters with swarms of coastguard vessels. While Vietnam has recently dialed down anti-Chinese rhetoric and sought closer diplomatic ties with Beijing, its actions on the water tell a different story. Over the past three years, Vietnam has pumped sand around at least 20 reefs, created 11 new harbours, and now controls more than 11 sq km of reclaimed land—about half of China's total—along with building military-grade infrastructure.
Greg Poling, director of the Washington-based Asian Maritime Transparency Initiative, notes that Vietnam prefers to let the Philippines fight the public relations battle while taking a firmer stand on the water, successfully resisting Chinese interference in oil and gas drilling. Ray Powell of Stanford University's Sealight project suggests the rapid construction on Antelope Reef is China's direct response, reminding Vietnam of who the "big dog on the porch" is after Vietnam took advantage of China's focus on the Philippines.
Meanwhile, decades of ASEAN negotiations for a binding code of conduct have stalled, and China has ignored the 2016 Permanent Court of Arbitration ruling favoring the Philippines. The Philippines has responded by publicly challenging Chinese flotillas with outnumbered coastguard ships, leading to frequent clashes, and expanding military cooperation with the US, Japan, and Australia. With a binding agreement seemingly out of reach, the new reality in the South China Sea is every nation for itself: claimants are consolidating what they control, accepting that China will remain the most assertive power on the water.