India's CBSE Exam Scandal Sparks Student Outrage
Against PM Modi
Nandini Singh had waited weeks for her high school examination results, which would determine her college admissions. When the scores were released on May 13, she was devastated to find her chemistry marks significantly lower than expected. She debated requesting a review but let the window lapse. Now, she is convinced she was cheated out of her rightful score, and her faith in the Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE), which conducts one of the world's largest school-leaving examinations, is shattered. “They are liars and a corrupt bunch of people taking our lives, our future hostage,” Singh told Al Jazeera from her home in Dehradun.
Singh is far from alone in her anger. Over 1.7 million students sat for the CBSE exams held between February 17 and April 10 this year. Now, many find themselves in limbo as the results have come under a cloud of suspicion following revelations about the board's rushed digital answer-sheet evaluation process. Student-led exposures have snowballed into outrage against Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s government, with growing calls for Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan to resign.
At the center of the controversy is the On-Screen Marking system introduced this year to evaluate millions of answer sheets. After papers are written, they are scanned and uploaded for evaluators to mark electronically. However, the system has been plagued by blurry scans, technical glitches, server outages, and delayed resolutions, casting a shadow over the futures of millions of students.
The system's implementation has drawn widespread ire. The CBSE floated bids for private companies but found no takers in the first two rounds. With only six months until the exams, the board reduced major technical requirements—like image quality and penalties for errors—and awarded the contract to Coempt Edu Teck, a Hyderabad-based company. This firm is no stranger to similar controversies. In April 2019, at least 20 students died by suicide after roughly 40 percent of students failed an exam in Telangana state. The answer sheets in that incident were digitized by Globarena Technologies Private Limited, which changed its name to Coempt Edu Teck following the public backlash before winning the current CBSE bid. This connection was unearthed by 18-year-old recent graduate Sarthak Sidhant from Ranchi, who wrote in his investigation: “This is a story of how a massive public institution deliberately played with students’ futures by rewriting its own rulebook.”
The wave of disclosures began with high school students speaking out. Vedant Srivastava’s social media post went viral after he requested to review his answer sheets and discovered the scanned copy provided by the CBSE was not his, featuring entirely different handwriting. “I studied for an entire year. I sacrificed sleep, peace of mind, outings, everything for these exams. And now I don’t even know whether MY actual Physics paper was checked,” Srivastava wrote. The CBSE acknowledged the error, manually re-evaluated his paper, and updated his results, but his post triggered a flood of similar complaints regarding incorrect marking.
Furthermore, 19-year-old Nisarga Adhikary from Bengaluru exposed severe vulnerabilities in the CBSE’s On-Screen Marking portal, claiming he could log in as an examiner and edit marks. Adhikary reported these issues to the CBSE in February but made them public after they remained unresolved following the results. Pranesh Prakash, co-founder of the Centre for Internet and Society in Delhi, noted that India lacks incentive programs for vulnerability reporting, warning that such flaws often end up on the black market. Delhi University professor Apoorvanand argued this is not an isolated incident. The National Testing Agency, responsible for nationwide exams, has faced repeated controversies over paper leaks. “The government has been indifferent towards people... Students have lost trust in the institutions. They know that they are being cheated, but they take it as their fate because any form of dissent is criminalized,” Apoorvanand told Al Jazeera.
Politically, the opposition is circling Education Minister Pradhan. Following the outrage, the government transferred the CBSE chairman and secretary to other departments on Tuesday. Opposition leader Rahul Gandhi labeled the move a “cover-up,” alleging the “real culprit,” the education minister, was spared. Congress Party spokesperson Jairam Ramesh accused the government of deflecting blame from political leadership onto bureaucrats. Aam Aadmi Party chief Arvind Kejriwal stated the transfers had “sprinkled salt on the wounds of millions of children and their parents.”
For students like recent graduate Prateek Singh from Raebareli, the fiasco breeds a deep sense of helplessness. For days after the results, the CBSE’s reevaluation website remained inaccessible. “This result will linger behind me like a shadow for the rest of my life,” Singh told Al Jazeera. “It would dictate my college admission, then a job, if ever. And I will always think that maybe the examiner did not even read my answers.”